Supporters' Shield champions Nashville SC (No. 1) begin their Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs journey when hosting Eastern Conference Wild Card winners FC Cincinnati (No. 9) on Sunday afternoon (4 pm ET | Apple TV).
Here are five key storylines as Hany Mukhtar and the Coyotes welcome the Evander-led Orange & Blue for Game 1 of their Round One Best-of-3 Series.
The series winner will face Chicago Fire FC (No. 4) or Charlotte FC (No. 5) in the Eastern Conference Semifinals, moving one step closer to MLS Cup presented by Audi on Dec. 18.
⚽🏆 ALL FOR THE CUP
Every match matters. Don't miss a moment of the Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs.
Nashville SC have already laid claim to the best statistical regular-season campaign in MLS history, setting a league record with 77 points.
They won more games than any team in league history (23), lost the fewest (3), conceded the fewest goals (25) and won the Shield by the largest margin ever (13 points), among other milestones.
Can Nashville secure their place in MLS immortality by lifting the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy? They'll lean on the marquee Designated Player attacking trio of Mukhtar (17g/8a), Sam Surridge (21g/2a) and Cristian Espinoza (4g/15a) to make even more history.
Cincinnati boast difference makers of their own, specifically Evander.
The two-time MLS Best XI selection asserted his elite bona fides with a 2g/1a performance in Wednesday's 3-1 Wild Card victory at Orlando City.
That's in addition to his 31 goal contributions (14g/17a) – second only to Inter Miami CF superstar Lionel Messi – during the regular season, which earned him a third straight Landon Donovan MLS MVP nomination.
No team in MLS history accrued as many points at home as Nashville (47) did in 2026.
Unbeaten at GEODIS Park, the Coyotes produced a record 15 home wins this season (15W-0L-2D), including eight clean sheets. They even beat the No. 2, No. 3, No. 4 and No. 5 teams in the Eastern Conference by a combined 15-4 scoreline.
As a result, Nashville have secured priority hosting rights as far as they go in the playoffs – all the way through MLS Cup on Dec. 18.
For all their offensive firepower, Nashville were also a historically dominant defensive unit in 2026. The Coyotes conceded just 25 goals, the fewest ever in a 34-game regular season.
This led to Maxwell Woledzi taking Defender of the Year honors, beating out teammates Jeisson Palacios and Andy Nájar for the award. Meanwhile, USMNT newcomer Brian Schwake is among the Goalkeeper of the Year finalists after notching a league-best 16 clean sheets.
By contrast, Cincinnati gave up three times as many goals (75), which was third-worst in MLS.
Cincy's games averaged 4.18 total goals during the regular season, a trend that continued into Wednesday's 3-1 Wild Card result. However, goalkeeper Roman Celentano's six-save performance helped put the Orange & Blue on the winning side of the equation.
If recent history is any indication, Nashville's Supporters' Shield success won't necessarily translate to MLS Cup glory.
Only two teams in the past 14 seasons have accomplished the rare MLS Cup-Supporters' Shield double: LAFC (2022) and Toronto FC (2017).
And since TFC's historic treble-winning 2017 campaign, four Shield winners have broken the MLS single-season points record (2018 Red Bull New York, 2019 LAFC, 2021 New England Revolution and 2024 Inter Miami) before falling short in the playoffs.
Will Nashville break the trend or become another record-breaking Shield winner with no MLS Cup to show for it?




